Projo Subterranean Homepage News

Bottom-up journalism from the pros: News, tech and culture by Sheila Lennon

Providence ranked 22nd-smartest city at Tina Brown's 'Daily Beast'

3:09 PM Mon, Oct 12, 2009 |
By Sheila Lennon    Email this author |   Email this entry

Former Vanity Fair and New Yorker editor Tina Brown's Daily Beast site ranks America's Smartest Cities--From First to Worst and Providence is #22:

#22, PROVIDENCE
Metro Area Population: 1,596,611
Daily Beast IQ Score: 110

Providence is home to half of Rhode Island's institutions of higher education, including Brown, and postsecondary students comprise one-quarter of the city's population. So it's no wonder that the Renaissance City's top 5 percent score in postsecondary institutions places it in the top half of our list, despite otherwise unexceptional numbers.

25% of the intelligence ranking comes from nonfiction book sales, where we seem to be unexceptional. The Web has certainly collapsed my cookbook buying.

Oddly,

The education half encompassed how many residents had bachelor's degrees (35 percent weighting) and graduate degrees (15 percent). No credit was given for "some college," or "some grad school"--we rewarded those who finished the race.

This seems to leave out the students, "one-quarter of the city's population."

But the actual race is life, to most of us: Money woes and financial burdens, job offers, boredom, a better idea, parenthood, illness or wanderlust all can lead to dropping out before the next degree. Goals change. This is a silly bias, and a myopically narrow gauge of intelligence.

The full list:


1. Raleigh-Durham
2. San Francisco-Oakland-San Jose
3. Boston
4. Minneapolis-St. Paul
5. Denver
6. Hartford-New Haven
7. (tie) Seattle-Tacoma,
7. (tie) Washington, DC
9. Portland
10. Baltimore
11. Philadelphia
12. Austin
13. New York
14. Salt Lake City
15. Milwaukee
16. Charlotte
17. (tie) Kansas City
17. (tie) Columbus
19. Nashville
20. (tie) San Diego
20. (tie) Indianapolis
22. Providence
23. Atlanta
24. (tie) St. Louis
24. (tie) Chicago
26. Rochester, NY
27. (tie) Pittsburgh
27. (tie) Los Angeles
27. (tie) Richmond
30. Grand Rapis-Kalamazoo-Battle Creek
31. (tie) Cleveland
31. (tie) West Palm Beach
33. Tampa-St. Petersburg
34. Tucson
35. (tie) Oklahoma City
35. (tie) Sacramento
37. (tie) Greensboro, NC
37. (tie) Jacksonville, FL
39. Miami
40. Detroit
41. Norfolk, VA
42. Birmingham
43. Cincinatti
44. Buffalo
45. New Orleans
46. (tie) Houston
46. (tie) Orlando
48. Dallas-Fort Worth
49. Phoenix
50. Harrisburg, PA
51. Memphis
52. Louisville
53. San Antonio
54. Las Vegas
55. Fresno, CA

Bookmark and Share

2 Comments

Jorn said:

I'm toying with the idea that counting _misspellings_ will give a rough measure of IQ for different websites, and that the misspelling themselves can be ranked from dumber to smarter:

low iq

in tact/intact
to/too
lose/loose
-ys/-ies
'nt/n't
alot/a lot
you're/your
than/then
threw/through
who's/whose

its/it's

[apostrophes]

their/there

consensus/concensus
led/lead

high iq

ps-- your captcha system SUCKS-- if it's not necessary for previews, the preview button should be above the captcha, and there should be a button specifically labeled different-captcha



The most common misspelling I've seen in news copy is commerical. It's a finger typo, I think, just comes out that way.

As for intelligence, how about ranking cities by the percentage of resdients who fell for Nigerian spam scams?

Good idea about changing the captcha process, jorn. I'll look into it tomorrow. Btw, you get used to that flaky font. I usually type it right on my first try these days.




Leave a comment





Type the characters you see in the picture above.